TGF 041 Gary Hilton: Uncovered
In this episode of The Guilty Files: Uncovered, Brian pulls back the curtain on one of the most chilling and calculated serial killers to ever stalk America’s wilderness—Gary Michael Hilton.Known as “The National Forest Killer,” Hilton used the vast, unguarded expanses of America's public lands as his personal hunting ground. Between 2007 and 2008, Hilton committed a series of brutal murders across Georgia, North Carolina, and Florida, targeting hikers, campers, and outdoor enthusiasts who thought they were safe in nature’s solitude.
Brian walks listeners through Hilton’s disturbing background, unraveling how a drifter with a manipulative charm and a long history of mental instability evolved into a predator who eluded capture for far too long. From the disappearance and beheading of 24-year-old Meredith Emerson in the North Georgia mountains, to the murders of John and Irene Bryant on a remote trail in North Carolina, and the horrifying fate of Sunday school teacher Cheryl Dunlap in Florida, this case is as horrifying as it is haunting.
This episode also examines the multi-jurisdictional manhunt, the forensic missteps, and the red flags missed by authorities over the years. Brian takes a methodical and investigative approach, analyzing Hilton’s patterns, his use of national forests to evade detection, and the terrifying reality that these killings weren’t just crimes of opportunity—they were calculated acts by a killer who knew how to blend into the backwoods like a ghost.
But there’s more to this case than the murders themselves. Brian also digs into the psychology of a man who weaponized loneliness, manipulated trust, and left a trail of trauma stretching across the southeastern United States. If you think the wilderness is peaceful, this story will make you think twice.
Listener discretion is strongly advised. The episode contains details of violent crimes and disturbing behavior that may not be suitable for all audiences. Be sure to follow and subscribe to The Guilty Files wherever you get your podcasts.
For bonus segments, behind-the-scenes content, and deeper dives into the case, join us on Patreon. And as always—stay curious, question everything, and never trust a closed case.
TGF 042 Gary Hilton: Rewired
What makes a man vanish into the woods—only to return as a predator? In this week's ReWired, Dani ventures into the haunted trailheads of the human psyche to unpack the chilling case of Gary Michael Hilton, a drifter-turned-serial killer whose victims were hikers, wanderers, and lovers of the wild. But this isn’t just a rehash of his crimes—it’s an excavation. We peel back the camouflage of Hilton’s mind to explore:
Why the wilderness became both his refuge and his hunting ground
How psychological detachment and transient identity fueled his violence
Whether a different intervention—or system—might have stopped him
And the deeply unsettling question: was Hilton always a killer-in-waiting, or was he shaped by what we overlooked?
Dani dissects the justice system’s blind spots, the human cost of being ignored or misidentified, and the terrifying allure of the wilderness when survival turns sinister. This isn’t just about murder in the mountains—it’s about the cracks in society where monsters take root.✨
Plus, an unforgettable personal story from Dani’s time in law enforcement—a haunting case that still lingers unsolved, echoing the same bystander indifference and missed chances.
🎙️ Stick around for the wrap-up where Dani recaps the layers of this psychological deep dive and teases what’s next: a no-holds-barred co-hosted finale with Brian on The Guilty Files: ReVisited, where everything you thought you knew about this case gets turned inside out.
TGF 044 Gary Micheal Hilton: Revisited
In this week's Revisited episode, Brian and Dani pull no punches as they dive into the chilling case of Gary Michael Hilton—the so-called “National Forest Serial Killer.” With his string of murders stretching across state lines and spanning years, Hilton’s case exposes glaring gaps in communication between law enforcement jurisdictions and raises disturbing questions about how someone so unstable could fly under the radar for so long.
Brian brings a procedural breakdown of the timeline, the forensic fumbles, and the legal aftermath, while Dani takes us deep into the psychological shadows—unpacking Hilton’s erratic behaviors, emotional detachment, and obsession with control. The banter is sharp, the insights are real, and the stakes? As high as the Appalachian peaks Hilton once stalked.And because we’re nothing if not ride-or-die for our listeners, we’ve got something special for you at the end of this week’s episode.
Stick around all the way to the end because we’re dropping all three of our subscriber-only bonus segments right here in this very episode as a thank you for powering through our scheduling hiccups this week. You’ll hear The Redacted Report, where Brian exposes the lesser-known files and nearly buried truths.
Then it’s Inside The Mind, where Dani takes you on a psychological deep-dive into what really drives a killer like Hilton.
And finally, Behind The Badge, where both hosts throw off the gloves for an unfiltered, behind-the-scenes look at what it’s like navigating cases like this from inside the system.
This is your one-time sneak peek into the bonus content we drop every week for subscribers. If you want more—more insights, more access, and more of The Guilty Files—click the link right here in the show notes to join us on Patreon, or if you’re listening on Apple Podcasts, hit that subscribe button to become a Guilty Files Detective. With either subscription, you’ll get early access to every episode, ad-free listening, and all three exclusive bonus segments for every single case.Thanks for sticking with us. Now buckle up—because this one gets dark.
Become A Detective